Skip to main content
Helcim raises $53 Million Series C to bring fair payments to businesses

Best 6 merchant service provider in U.S. and Canada

“The best 6 merchant service providers in the U.S. and Canada: Compare fees, features, tools, contracts, fraud protection, and more.”

Robert Luong Robert Luong 29 min read
Best 6 merchant service provider in U.S. and Canada

A merchant service provider gives your business a way to accept credit card, debit card and ACH/EFT bank payments, then deposits that money into your bank account. In this article, we will compare different merchant service providers’ fees, costs, features, strengths and limitations so that you can choose the best one for your business. Whether your business values affordability, development tools, or in-person payment hardware, you will find valuable information in this article.

TLDR

  • Choose Helcim if you run a small or mid-sized business in the U.S. or Canada and want cheaper credit card processing fees as you grow. You pay interchange-plus rates (about 1.78% + 8¢ in person in the U.S.), with $0 monthly fees, no contract, and a POS, invoicing, recurring billing and online store included.
  • Choose Square if you are just starting out, sell mostly in person, and want a plug-and-play POS today. The flat 2.6% + 15¢ rate is simple, but it never drops on its own, and Square only negotiates custom pricing once you pass $250,000 a year. Square isn’t a great choice for U.S. businesses that accept lots of debit card transactions because it charges the same high credit card rates for debit cards.
  • Choose Stripe if you have developers and sell online to customers around the world. It supports 135+ currencies and can act as your Merchant of Record, but online cards cost 2.9% + 30¢ and every dispute costs at least $15, even when you win. Stripe isn't suitable for businesses that don’t have a development team or look for ready-to-use POS software or inventory management tools.
  • Choose PayPal if your online shoppers expect a PayPal or Venmo button at checkout. Treat it as an extra checkout option rather than your main merchant service provider, because wallet payments cost 3.49% + 49¢ in the U.S. and currency conversion adds 3% to 4%. PayPal isn’t suitable for growing businesses because of the expensive payment processing fees, or any Canadian business that needs in-person payments.
  • Choose Authorize.net if you run an eCommerce store or wholesaling business because Authorize.net can connect to more than 170 shopping carts and store up to 100 shipping locations per customer profile. However, Authorize.net isn’t suitable for in-person businesses because it charges a high payment processing fee of 2.9% + 30¢ even for debit or in-person credit card transactions.
  • Choose Global Payments only if you are a large business that can negotiate favorable pricing and contracts. Global Payments can connect to major enterprise software like Microsoft Dynamics, Acumatica, SAP, and Sage. But, Global Payments is a risky choice for small and mid-sized businesses who don't like contracts or paying various hidden fees.
Helcim Square Stripe PayPal Authorize.net Global Payments
Best for Growing small and mid-sized businesses in the U.S. and Canada New businesses that sell mostly in person Online businesses with developers that sell worldwide Online stores that want a PayPal or Venmo button eCommerce stores that need a shopping cart gateway Large businesses that can negotiate custom pricing
Pricing model Interchange-plus, with automatic volume discounts Flat rate Flat rate Flat rate Flat rate (All-in-One) Varies by contract
U.S. in-person credit card rate From interchange + 0.40% + 8¢ (about 1.78% + 8¢) 2.6% + 15¢ 2.7% + 5¢ 2.29% + 9¢ 2.9% + 30¢ Custom quote
Canada in-person credit card rate From interchange + 0.40% + 8¢ (about 1.72% + 8¢) 2.5% 2.7% + 5¢ Unavailable 2.9% + 30¢ Custom quote
U.S. online credit card rate From interchange + 0.50% + 25¢ (about 2.29% + 25¢) 3.3% + 30¢ (2.9% + 30¢ on paid plans) 2.9% + 30¢ 2.99% + 49¢ for cards; 3.49% + 49¢ for PayPal and Venmo 2.9% + 30¢ Custom quote
Canada online credit card rate From interchange + 0.50% + 25¢ (about 2.38% + 25¢) 2.8% + 30¢ 2.9% + 30¢ 2.90% + 30¢ 2.9% + 30¢ Custom quote
U.S. in-person debit card rate 1.00% + 8¢ Same as credit (2.6% + 15¢) Same as credit (2.7% + 5¢) Same as credit (2.29% + 9¢) Same as credit (2.9% + 30¢) Custom quote
Canada in-person debit card rate $0.09 flat (Interac) 0.75% + 7¢ (Interac) $0.15 flat (Interac) Unavailable 2.9% + 30¢ Custom quote
U.S. ACH rate 0.5% + 25¢, capped at $6 1% ($1 minimum; no cap on Square Free, $10 cap on paid Invoices plans) 0.8%, capped at $5 1%, capped at $10 (Invoicing); 0.75%, capped at $5 (Braintree) 0.75% per eCheck ($10 monthly minimum) Custom quote
Canada EFT rate 0.5% + 25¢, capped at $6 Not supported 1% + 40¢, capped at $5 Not supported Not supported Custom quote
Monthly fee $0 $0 on Square Free; Plus $49, Premium $149 $0 $0 for a standard account $25 Statement, gateway and PCI fees of roughly $45 to $125
Contract None, month-to-month None None None No fixed term, but the account can't be paused Usually 36 to 60 months, $500+ termination fee
Chargeback fee $15 if you lose, $0 if you win $0 $15, plus $15 to contest (refunded only if you win) $20 USD / $20 CAD $25, never refunded $25 USD / $35 CAD, never refunded

Best merchant service provider in U.S. and Canada

Helcim

Helcim is a merchant service provider that serves businesses in the U.S. and Canada. Helcim is famous for its interchange-plus pricing model that offers transparent and affordable credit card processing rates for all types of businesses instead of only enterprises like other providers. With automatic volume discounts, Helcim helps businesses save on processing fees as they grow without negotiations or minimum processing volume commitments. Explore Helcim pricing here.

Helcim monthly fees

Fee U.S. Canada
Standard monthly plans $0 $0
Paid software plans None. All tools included None. All tools included
Gateway fee $0 $0
PCI compliance fee $0 $0
Monthly minimum None None
Hardware rental or lease None. Hardware is bought outright; optional mobile data plan $7/month None. Hardware is bought outright; optional mobile data plan $9 CAD/month

Helcim payment processing fees

Payment type U.S. Canada
Pricing model Interchange-plus Interchange-plus
In-person credit card Interchange + 0.40% + 8¢ (average 1.78% + 8¢) Interchange + 0.40% + 8¢ (average 1.72% + 8¢)
Online credit card Interchange + 0.50% + 25¢ (average 2.29% + 25¢) Interchange + 0.50% + 25¢ (average 2.38% + 25¢)
Keyed-in / virtual terminal Same as online Same as online
In-person debit card 1.00% + 8¢ $0.09 flat (Interac)
ACH / EFT bank payment 0.5% + 25¢, capped at $6 for transaction below $25K, and costs extra 0.05% for payments above $25K 0.5% + 25¢, capped at $6 for transaction below $25K, and costs extra 0.05% for payments above $25K
HSA / FSA cards Accepted in person and online at card rates Accepted in person and online at card rates
International cards Accepted; priced at interchange-plus Accepted; priced at interchange-plus
Recurring billing +0.4% per recurring transaction +0.4% per recurring transaction
Tap to Pay on iPhone +10¢ per transaction Unavailable
Volume discounts Automatic, up to 70% off the margin; as low as interchange + 0.15% + 6¢ in person at $1M+/month Automatic, up to 70% off the margin; as low as interchange + 0.15% + 6¢ in person at $1M+/month

Average rates listed above are for monthly volume under $50,000. Helcim uses an interchange-plus pricing model that passes the true transaction fees charged by banks and payment networks to merchants. These true fees vary every transaction. Average fees are based on common credit cards, excluding American Express, and an average transaction amount of $300.

compare Helcim credit card processing fees against others

Other Helcim fees

Fee U.S. Canada
Chargeback $15 if you lose; $0 if you win $15 if you lose; $0 if you win
ACH / EFT return $5 $5
Currency conversion No Helcim fee; the customer's bank converts No Helcim fee; the customer's bank converts
Contract cancellation $0, month-to-month $0, month-to-month
Inactivity fee None None
Faster or instant deposits Free next-business-day deposits (RTP / FedNow) Free next-business-day deposits (Interac, batches up to $25,000)

Helcim merchant services features

Merchants can buy Helcim POS payment hardware outright without having to sign any leasing contract. The Helcim Card Reader costs $199 USD / $249 CAD and the Helcim Smart Terminal costs $349 USD / $429 CAD, or monthly installments. For businesses that have to accept payments on the go without Wi-Fi, they can subscribe to Helcim's optional 4G/LTE SIM card that can be installed in the Helcim Smart Terminal for an internet connection. U.S. businesses can also get Helcim Tap to Pay on iPhone to accept contactless payments on an iPhone with no reader at all.

Aside from in-person payment hardware, Helcim offers multiple online payment tools at no monthly cost and with no per-user fees:

  • The cloud Helcim POS software and app for phones, tablets, laptops, and computers so that businesses can accept in-person payments without buying a POS register.
  • The Helcim Virtual Terminal for over-the-phone payments, pre-authorizations, or collecting overdue invoices.
  • The Helcim Invoicing with a Pay Now button, automatic reminders, partial payments and HIPAA-compliant billing
  • The Helcim Recurring Payments for subscriptions, installments, memberships and payment plans.
  • The Helcim online storefront builder, hosted payment pages, QR codes and payment links.
  • The Helcim Customer Manager with a self-service portal so that customers can manage their personal and payment information by themselves.
  • The Helcim Fee Saver that lets businesses pass credit card processing fees to customers where allowed.
  • The Helcim Level 2/3 credit card processing that helps businesses reduce credit card rates to as low as 1.45% when the customers pay by business and corporate credit cards.
  • The Helcim Payment Extension that helps businesses connect Helcim payment processing to more than 70 (and counting) different business management, accounting, EHR, auto shop, etc. software applications.
  • Helcim API and HelcimPay.js that allow medium and big businesses with development resources to build a customized payment experience for their website and software.

For security feature, Helcim takes care of PCI compliance for you and doesn’t charge a PCI fee. The customers' cards are saved and protected with AES-256 encryption and replaced with secure tokens, and Helcim never keeps the CVV codes. Each staff member gets their own login with role-based access and a personal PIN, and healthcare businesses get HIPAA-compliant invoicing, with a Business Associate Agreement available on request.

Helcim strengths

  • Helcim credit card processing fees drop automatically as your sales grow, with no plan upgrade or sales call needed. In contrast, other merchant service providers require merchants to contact, negotiate, sign a contract, and commit to minimum processing volume.
  • Helcim charges affordable debit card transaction fees for U.S. debit (1.00% + 8¢) and Canadian Interac ($0.09). In contrast, other merchant service providers like Square or Authorize.net charge the same expensive credit card rate for U.S. debit transactions, 2.6% + 15¢.
  • Helcim offers affordable ACH/EFT bank transfer rates compared to other merchant service providers.
  • Helcim doesn’t charge any monthly, PCI, setup, statement or cancellation fees, and doesn’t require a merchant service contract.
  • All Helcim payment tools like POS software, virtual terminal, invoicing, recurring billing, an online store, a customer portal, and inventory management are all included for free. Merchants only need to pay for payment processing fees.
  • Helcim provides HIPAA-compliant merchant services so that healthcare clinics can accept payments and HSA/FSA while protecting patients’ information.
  • Helcim Payment Extension allows businesses to connect Helcim's affordable merchant services to other software so that merchants don’t have to sacrifice their software and existing workflow to use Helcim.

Helcim credit card processing volume discount

Helcim weaknesses

  • Helcim Interchange-plus passes the true rate of each transaction to the merchant, and this true rate fluctuates. So, Helcim credit card rates are harder to predict and forecast.
  • Helcim does not offer a buy now, pay later feature or a PayPal/Venmo wallet button on a customized checkout page.
  • Helcim does not offer POS registers or specialized hospitality features like coursing, table mapping, or kitchen display systems, so full-service restaurants or busy retailers that need a specialized POS register and ordering system may find Helcim unsuitable.
  • Currently, Helcim offers Tap to Pay on iPhone only for U.S. businesses and Helcim doesn’t offer Tap to Pay on Android yet.

Who should use Helcim

Helcim fits most small and mid-sized businesses in the U.S. and Canada that take payments in person, online, by invoice, or over the phone, from retail shops and salons to contractors, clinics, and wholesalers. Helcim is also especially suitable for growing businesses, because Helcim credit card processing fees keep falling as the business’s sales volume increases. Besides, B2B businesses or those that sell high-value products or services can use Helcim ACH payments or Level 2/3 credit card processing to further reduce payment processing fees. Helcim is not the right choice for businesses based outside North America, sellers who need global multi-currency checkout, or large restaurants that need advanced kitchen and coursing features.

sign up Helcim for free

Square

Square is a merchant service provider that offers flat-rate credit card processing and ACH transfers (only for U.S. businesses). Besides, Square offers both free POS software and paid subscription plans with industry-specific features for restaurants, retail, and services.

Square monthly fees

Fee U.S. Canada
Standard monthly plans $0 on Square Free; $49/month on Square Plus ; $149/month on Square Premium $0 on Square Free; $35+/month on Square Plus
Industry-specific monthly plans Industry features are a part of standard monthly plans $60/month on Restaurant Plus; $79/month per location on Retail Plus; $35 to $85/month for appointment feature
Gateway fee $0 $0
PCI compliance fee $0 $0
Monthly minimum None None

Square payment processing fees

Payment type U.S. Canada
Pricing model Flat rate Flat rate
In-person credit card 2.6% + 15¢ (Free); 2.5% + 15¢ (Plus); 2.4% + 15¢ (Premium) 2.5%
Online credit card 3.3% + 30¢ (Free); 2.9% + 30¢ (Plus/Premium and eCommerce API) 2.8% + 30¢
Keyed-in / virtual terminal 3.5% + 15¢ 3.3% + 15¢
In-person debit card Same as credit (2.6% + 15¢ on Free) 0.75% + 7¢ (Interac)
ACH / EFT bank payment 1% ($1 minimum; no cap on Free, $10 cap on paid Invoices plans, $5 cap via API) Not available
HSA / FSA cards Not published Not published
International cards +1.5% per transaction +1.5% per transaction
Recurring billing Same as online rate Same as online rate
Afterpay (buy now, pay later) 6% + 30¢ 6% + 30¢
Volume discounts Custom pricing is available for businesses process over $250,000/year Custom pricing is available for businesses process over $250,000/year

Other Square fees

Fee U.S. Canada
Chargeback $0 fee, but you lose the sale amount if you lose $0 fee, but you lose the sale amount if you lose
ACH / EFT return Not published Not applicable
Currency conversion Not published Not published
Contract cancellation $0 $0
Inactivity fee None None
Faster or instant deposits 1.95% of the transfer 1.95% of the transfer

Square merchant services features

Square offers the Square Reader ($59 / $69 CAD), Square Stand for iPad ($149 / $249 CAD), Square Terminal with a built-in printer ($299 / $399 CAD), Square Handheld with a barcode scanner ($399 / $449 CAD), Square Register with two screens ($899 / $999 CAD) and a self-order Kiosk ($1,999). Square Tap to Pay on iPhone and Android are free, and devices keep working in offline mode for up to 24 hours.

For online payment processing, Square offers Square Online, virtual terminal, recurring payments, invoicing, payment links, Afterpay, and Cash App Pay (for U.S. businesses).

For security features, similar to Helcim, Square handles PCI compliance for you at no extra cost. It also monitors accounts automatically for unusual activity. Keep in mind that Square’s dispute protection doesn’t cover keyed-in payments, and you take the full loss if an offline payment is later declined.

Square strengths

  • Square offers Tap to Pay on mobile for both iPhone and Android, so businesses can start accepting payments without buying any payment hardware.
  • The offline mode helps the Square POS system process payments even during an internet outage.
  • Square paid subscription plans offer different business management features for restaurants, retailers, and salons.
  • Square offers different POS hardware that is useful for the hospitality industry, such as the dual-screen Register, self-ordering Kiosk, and Kitchen Display System.
  • Square charges no credit card chargeback fee, while all other merchant service providers on the list charge a chargeback fee of at least $15 per chargeback.

Square weaknesses

  • In the U.S., Square charges debit card transactions the same 2.6% + 15¢ as credit card transactions. In contrast, Helcim charges an affordable rate for debit cards, 1.00% + 8¢.
  • Square lowers credit card processing fees only when merchants subscribe to paid subscription plans or through negotiation when they process at least $250,000 per month. In contrast, Helcim offers automatic discounts for all businesses without paid plans required.
  • Square doesn’t support EFT bank transfers for Canadian businesses, while Helcim offers ACH and EFT bank transfers for both U.S. and Canadian businesses, respectively.
  • Square payment hardware only works with Square, so businesses have to quit their old POS system to completely switch to Square. In contrast, Helcim offers an integrated payment API so that businesses can integrate the Helcim Smart Terminal into their existing POS system.
  • Square doesn’t offer Level 2/3 credit card processing for B2B sellers to reduce business and corporate credit card processing fees.

Who should use Square

Square is a great fit for businesses in hospitality industries such as cafes, food trucks, retailers, or restaurants, thanks to different POS hardware like the dual-screen Register, self-ordering Kiosk, and Kitchen Display System. Besides, businesses that need operational or appointment features can subscribe to Square paid subscription plans for them instead of getting external software.

Square isn’t a great choice for U.S. businesses that accept lots of debit card transactions because it charges the same high credit card rates for debit cards. In addition, businesses that process lots of business and corporate card transactions cannot save extra with Square because it doesn’t offer Level 2/3 credit card processing like Helcim.

Read more about Helcim vs Square.

Stripe

Stripe is a merchant service provider that offers a powerful payment API. Developers love Stripe because they can use the Stripe API to build complex checkout experiences for apps, software, and websites, and even revenue-sharing logic for marketplace platforms. Stripe also offers many online payment tools. However, Stripe’s biggest limitation is the lack of out-of-the-box POS features like inventory management or POS software.

Stripe monthly fees

Fee U.S. Canada
Standard monthly plans $0 $0
Gateway fee $0 $0
PCI compliance fee $0 $0
Monthly minimum None on standard pricing None on standard pricing

Stripe payment processing fees

Payment type U.S. Canada
Pricing model Flat rate (interchange-plus by negotiation) Flat rate (interchange-plus by negotiation)
In-person credit card 2.7% + 5¢ 2.7% + 5¢ CAD
Online credit card 2.9% + 30¢ 2.9% + 30¢ CAD
Keyed-in / virtual terminal 2.9% + 30¢ + 0.5% 2.9% + 30¢ CAD + 0.5%
In-person debit card Same as credit card (2.7% + 5¢) $0.15 CAD flat (Interac)
ACH / EFT bank payment 0.8%, capped at $5 1% + 40¢ CAD, capped at $5 CAD
HSA / FSA cards Not published Not published
International cards +1.5% +0.8% online; 3.5% + 5¢ CAD in person
Recurring billing Stripe Billing adds 0.7% of billing volume Stripe Billing add-on fee applies
Tap to Pay on mobile +10¢ per transaction +15¢ per transaction
Volume discounts Volume discounts and custom interchange-plus is available through custom deals and negotiation Volume discounts and custom interchange-plus is available through custom deals and negotiation

Other Stripe fees

Fee U.S. Canada
Chargeback fee $15 chargeback fee (non-refundable) + $15 dispute the chargeback (refunded only if you win) $15 chargeback fee (non-refundable) + $15 dispute the chargeback (refunded only if you win)
ACH / EFT return $4 per failed ACH payment $5 CAD per failed or disputed PAD
Currency conversion +1% +2%
Contract cancellation $0 $0
Inactivity fee None None
Faster or instant deposits 1.5% of the payout (minimum 50¢) 1% of the payout (minimum 60¢ CAD)

Stripe merchant services features

Stripe Terminal readers include the Stripe Reader M2 ($59, U.S. only), the BBPOS WisePad 3 ($79, Canada only), and countertop or handheld smart payment terminals like the Stripe Reader S700 that costs $419 in Canada and $299 in the U.S. However, Stripe doesn’t offer a built-in POS system or inventory management, so small businesses have to connect Stripe hardware to external POS systems or develop their own POS system.

For online transactions, Stripe offers Stripe Checkout, Payment Links, Billing for subscriptions, and Invoicing. Stripe lets international customers pay with their local payment methods and supports more than 135 currencies. However, Stripe charges a currency conversion fee of 1% for U.S. and 2% for Canadian merchants, so merchants have to consider this fee when selling globally.

Stripe Billing can support metered/usage-based pricing, which is common in the SaaS industry. Besides, marketplaces can use Stripe Connect to build complex revenue-sharing logic for multiple buyers and sellers.

For security features, every Stripe account includes Radar, a fraud screening tool that trigger 3D secure verification when needed. All Stripe Terminal payments are end-to-end encrypted by default, and businesses in industries that require it can add PCI-certified point-to-point encryption for 5¢ per payment.

Stripe strengths

  • Stripe's APIs and SDKs let developers build almost any checkout, marketplace, or subscription flow. Enterprises and software companies love using Stripe because it gives them a lot of control over the payment experience.
  • Because Stripe supports more than 135 currencies, U.S. or Canadian businesses that sell globally can allow their customers to pay using their local payment method. This is something that most merchant service providers don’t offer.
  • Similar to Helcim, Stripe offers ACH/EFT bank transfers to both U.S. and Canadian businesses so that merchants can save on processing fees on high-value invoices and orders.

Stripe weaknesses

  • Stripe's affordable interchange-plus pricing and volume discounts are only available for enterprises, while Helcim offers both options for all businesses.
  • Most of Stripe's payment tools need coding to set up. Businesses without a developer will find Helcim's ready-to-use POS, invoicing, online store and payment pages much faster to get running.
  • Stripe charges a non-refundable chargeback fee of $15, and if businesses want to dispute the chargeback, they have to pay another fee of $15.
  • Stripe charges extra fees on top of the expensive payment processing fees, such as 0.7% extra for each recurring billing transaction, 0.5% extra per keyed-in transaction or 0.4% per paid invoice.
  • Stripe doesn’t offer a ready-to-use POS system and inventory management feature, so the merchants have to use an external system or develop their own POS system.

Who should use Stripe

Stripe is suitable for online businesses or enterprises with developers on staff, such as SaaS companies, marketplaces, apps and e-commerce brands that sell to customers in many countries. Stripe is also very useful if you need multi-currency checkout or want Stripe to handle international sales tax as your Merchant of Record.

Stripe isn't suitable for businesses that don’t have a development team or look for ready-to-use POS software or inventory management tools. Besides, businesses that look for affordable merchant services can find Stripe’s payment processing fees more expensive than Helcim.

Read more about Helcim vs Stripe.

PayPal

Businesses often use PayPal as a checkout button on their eCommerce checkout form. Besides, PayPal also offers all basic online payment tools like virtual terminal, invoicing, subscription billing, etc. PayPal only supports in-person merchant services for U.S. businesses. PayPal offers interchange-plus pricing to established businesses who are willing to apply and negotiate.

PayPal monthly fees

Fee U.S. Canada
Standard monthly plans $0 for a standard business account $0 for a standard business account; Payflow Pro costs $25 a month
Paid software plans Invoicing tool subscription ($14.99 a month) and account monitoring ($19.95 a month plus $29.95 setup) PayPal Recurring Billing ($10 a month)
Gateway fee Payflow Pro gateway $25/month Not published
PCI compliance fee None None
Monthly minimum None None

PayPal payment processing fees

Payment type U.S. Canada
Pricing model Flat rate (interchange-plus on Braintree by negotiation) Flat rate
In-person credit card 2.29% + 9¢ Unavailable
Online credit card 2.99% + 49¢ (standard checkout); 2.89% + 29¢ (Expanded Checkout / Braintree); PayPal and Venmo wallet 3.49% + 49¢ 2.90% + fixed fee
Keyed-in / virtual terminal 3.39% + 29¢ (virtual terminal); 3.49% + 9¢ (keyed on POS) 3.10% + fixed fee
In-person debit card Same as credit (2.29% + 9¢) Unavailable
ACH / EFT bank payment 1%, capped at $10 (Invoicing); 0.75%, capped at $5 (Braintree) Unavailable
HSA / FSA cards Not HIPAA compliant Not HIPAA compliant
International cards +1.5% +0.8% from the U.S.; +1% from other countries
Recurring billing 3.49% + 49¢ Not published
Buy Now Pay Later 4.99% + 49¢ 4.90% + fixed fee per transaction

Other PayPal fees

Fee U.S. Canada
Chargeback $20 per card chargeback, rising to $30 for high-dispute accounts $20 CAD per card chargeback, rising to $40 CAD for high-dispute accounts
ACH / EFT return $5 Not applicable
Currency conversion 3% to 4% above the base exchange rate At least 4% above the base exchange rate
Contract cancellation $0 $0
Inactivity fee None Up to $20 CAD per year on dormant accounts
Faster or instant deposits 1.5% (minimum 50¢) 1.5% (minimum 50¢ CAD)

PayPal merchant services features

In the U.S., PayPal offers a PayPal Card Reader that costs $29 for the first card reader and $79 for each additional one. The normal PayPal payment terminal costs $199 or $239 with a barcode scanner. In Canada, PayPal doesn’t support payment hardware and POS systems. PayPal Tap to Pay on mobile works on iPhone and Android.

For online payment processing, PayPal offers PayPal, Venmo, and Buy Now Pay Later buttons for checkout forms, payment links, online checkout, invoicing, a virtual terminal, and developer APIs with Level 2/3 data support.

PayPal Seller Protection covers eligible physical-goods orders against “item not received” and unauthorized-payment claims, and waives the chargeback fee on them. Card payments can add Chargeback Protection (0.40% in the U.S. / 0.80% in Canada) or Effortless Chargeback Protection (0.60% / 1.20%). Extra tools such as Fraud Protection Lite and the Buyer Authentication Service carry their own per-check or monthly fees.

PayPal strengths

  • Many shoppers, especially in the U.S., already have PayPal or Venmo, so they are more willing to pay at checkout with these payment methods.
  • PayPal Pay Later lets businesses offer Buy Now Pay Later at checkout, improving the conversion rate for high-value orders.
  • PayPal offers affordable entry-level card hardware in the U.S. For example, your first PayPal Card Reader costs just $29, making it a low-cost option for occasional in-person card acceptance.

PayPal weaknesses

  • PayPal charges extremely high online credit card processing fees, from 2.99% + 49¢ for standard checkout to 3.49% + 49¢ for recurring payment transactions.
  • PayPal doesn’t offer in-person merchant services, POS systems or payment hardware to Canadian businesses.
  • Businesses have to subscribe to paid plans for some features like Recurring Billing or Advanced Invoicing.
  • PayPal charges non-refundable credit card chargeback fees of $20 even if merchants win the chargeback disputes.
  • Canadian businesses also cannot take in-person card or Interac payments or EFT bank payments through PayPal, while Helcim supports all three.

Who should use PayPal

PayPal makes sense for online stores whose customers like to pay with PayPal, Venmo or Pay Later, especially as a second checkout button next to a lower-cost card processor. Very small sellers with occasional online sales may also like the no-monthly-fee account.

PayPal isn’t suitable for growing businesses because of expensive payment processing fees, or any Canadian business that needs in-person payments. For those businesses, Helcim's lower card rates, free POS software, and $0 currency conversion fee are usually the better deal.

Read more about Helcim vs PayPal.

Authorize.net

Authorize.net is a payment gateway owned by Visa. Businesses can buy it as an All-in-One package with a merchant account included.

Authorize.net monthly fees

Types of fees Costs
Standard monthly plans $25 per month
Paid software plans eCheck (ACH) add-on with a $10 monthly minimum
Gateway fee Included in the $25 monthly plan
PCI compliance fee Not published; set by your merchant account provider on Gateway Only
Monthly minimum $10 eCheck minimum
Hardware rental or lease No Authorize.net hardware; third-party readers bought through POS Portal

Authorize.net payment processing fees

Payment type U.S. Canada
Pricing model Flat-rate pricing Flat-rate pricing
In-person credit card 2.9% + 30¢ 2.9% + 30¢
Online credit card 2.9% + 30¢ 2.9% + 30¢
Keyed-in / virtual terminal 2.9% + 30¢ 2.9% + 30¢
In-person debit card Same as credit (2.9% + 30¢) Same as credit (2.9% + 30¢)
ACH / EFT bank payment 0.75% per eCheck 0.75% per eCheck
HSA / FSA cards Not listed in Authorize.net's fee schedule Not listed in Authorize.net's fee schedule
International cards +1.5% +1.5%
Recurring billing Included in the $25 monthly fee Included in the $25 monthly fee

Other Authorize.net fees

Fee U.S. Canada
Chargeback $25, never refunded (even if you win) $25, never refunded (even if you win)
ACH / EFT return $3 per returned eCheck ($25 if it is an unauthorized-debit dispute) $3 per returned eCheck ($25 if it is an unauthorized-debit dispute)
Contract cancellation No published fee, but you cannot pause the account; you must pay monthly or close it No published fee, but you cannot pause the account; you must pay monthly or close it
Inactivity fee $10 per billing cycle on abandoned accounts $10 per billing cycle on abandoned accounts
Late payment fee $20 $20
Returned billing payment fee $25 $25
Voice authorization fee $1.20 $1.20
Faster or instant deposits Not offered Not offered

Authorize.net merchant services features

Authorize.net does not make its own hardware. Therefore, U.S. and Canadian merchants need to buy certified readers such as the BBPOS Chipper 3X or a USB reader for Windows through POS Portal, or use Tap to Pay on iPhone or Android.

For online payment tools, Authorize.net offers a virtual terminal, hosted payment form, invoicing, Customer Information Manager for saved cards, Automated Recurring Billing, and the Advanced Fraud Detection Suite. Level 2/3 credit card processing is only available through its API. Besides, Authorize.net connects to 170+ shopping carts, including Shopify, WooCommerce, Magento, and BigCommerce.

For security feature, the $25 monthly fee includes the Advanced Fraud Detection Suite. It screens payments with filters for IP location, transaction speed, address verification and CVV, and blocks card-testing attempts. Saved cards are stored as tokens off your systems, which reduces your PCI compliance work. Its dispute alert network also gives you 72 hours to refund a customer before the dispute becomes a chargeback.

Authorize.net strengths

  • Authorize.net can connect to 170+ shopping carts so that eCommerce stores can set up the payment system easily.
  • If businesses save customer cards on file and they are expired, Authorize.net can refresh the cards’ details based on the information provided by Visa/Mastercard networks for a small per-update fee of $0.25 per successful update.
  • Authorize.net Customer Information Manager (CIM) lets businesses store up to 100 shipping locations per customer profile, which is useful for wholesale buyers or franchisors.

Authorize.net weaknesses

  • Businesses have to pay $25 a month whether they sell or not, and they cannot pause the account. In contrast, Helcim has no monthly or inactivity fee at all.
  • Authorize.net charges a 2.9% + 30¢ rate for every online and in-person credit card and debit card transaction. As a consequence, businesses overpay for debit card and in-person credit card transactions. For context, Helcim's average in-person rate is about 1.78% + 8¢ and U.S. debit is 1.00% + 8¢.
  • Authorize.net’s chargebacks cost $25 and are never refunded, even when you win.
  • Authorize.net has lots of other fees that can add up over time, such as a $20 late payment fee or a $25 returned billing payment fee.
  • Authorize.net in-person payment hardware is limited. Businesses have to get third-party hardware and connect it to Authorize.net.

Who should use Authorize.net

Authorize.net suits established U.S. eCommerce stores or wholesalers because businesses can connect Authorize.net to more than 170 shopping carts and store up to 100 shipping locations per customer profile.

However, Authorize.net isn’t suitable for in-person businesses because it charges a high payment processing fee of 2.9% + 30¢ even for debit or in-person credit card transactions. In contrast, Helcim's average in-person rate is about 1.78% + 8¢ and U.S. debit is 1.00% + 8¢.

Read more about Helcim vs Authorize.net.

Global Payments

Global Payments is a merchant service provider that owns brands like Heartland, Payrix and the Genius POS. To work with Global Payments, businesses have to contact its sales team instead of signing up online. Businesses can sign up through independent sales organizations (ISOs), which can set their own rates, contracts and equipment leases. That is why two Global Payments merchants can pay very different prices.

Global Payments payment processing fees and monthly fees

Global Payments doesn’t publish payment processing fees or monthly fees on its website. Usually, businesses are required to sign a merchant agreement contract that is around 36 or 60 months long with auto-renewing commitments and $500+ termination fees. Besides, Global Payments charges PCI non-compliance fees around $75–$99/month, batch fees, statement fees, and data monitoring fees, so businesses have to pay attention to these hidden fees before signing the contract.

Global Payments merchant services features

Global Payments’ hardware includes the Genius countertop POS, the Genius handheld with a built-in printer and scanner, and Verifone smart terminals. Hardware prices are not published. Larger restaurants can add kitchen display systems, drive-thru timers, and AI voice ordering.

For online payment tools, Global Payments offers a virtual terminal, invoicing tool, hosted payment pages, recurring billing, inventory catalogs, customer management, etc. Overall, it provides a complete list of payment processing tools for businesses to accept payments. Global Payments also has a broad footprint in corporate retail, legacy register systems, and institutional ERP networks.

For security features, Global Payments offers hosted payment fields, point-to-point encryption and card tokenization, which keep card data off your systems and cut your PCI compliance work down. Online checkouts can use 3-D Secure 2.0, which shifts liability for fraudulent chargebacks to the card issuer. Merchants that miss their annual PCI self-assessment can be charged a monthly non-compliance fee.

Global Payments strengths

  • Global Payments Genius POS offers deep restaurant features such as coursing, bar tabs, split-ticket resolution, and tip-out configuration, plus native delivery (DoorDash, Uber Eats) and loyalty (Como, Paytronix) integrations.
  • Its Invoicing tool can connect to major enterprise software like Microsoft Dynamics, Acumatica, SAP, and Sage.
  • Businesses can create incentive programs (such as gift cards or loyalty programs) to reward loyal customers.

Global Payments weaknesses

  • Global Payments’ rates are not published and depend on who signs you up, so businesses cannot know how much they will pay until they contact sales and read through the contract.
  • Global Payments charges monthly fees and other fees that can stack up quickly. For example, statement, gateway, PCI program, PCI non-compliance, and monthly minimum fees can add up to roughly $45 to $125 a month. In contrast, Helcim charges $0 for all of them.
  • Businesses may have to sign 36- or 60-month-long contracts with steep termination costs and liquidated damages to work with Global Payments. This contract locks businesses in so that they can’t switch when a better deal exists.

Who should use Global Payments

Global Payments is suitable for large enterprises, multi-location chains, big restaurants and companies with negotiating power to secure custom deals and favorable contracts and leases. However, Global Payments is a risky choice for small and mid-sized businesses because they have to commit to a contract, pay other hidden payment processing fees that drive up their costs, and face expensive termination fees if they want to switch merchant service providers.

Read more about Helcim vs Global Payments.

How to choose the best merchant service provider

The cheapest-looking rate is not always the cheapest provider. Work through these steps with your last few months of sales in front of you.

  1. Write down how your customers pay. Note how much you take in person, online, by invoice, over the phone and through subscriptions, and whether any customers pay by bank transfer (ACH in the U.S., EFT/PAD in Canada) or HSA/FSA card payments. A provider that is cheap in person can be expensive for keyed-in or online payments.
  2. Understand the pricing model. Flat-rate pricing (offered by Square, Stripe, PayPal, etc.) charges one percentage for every card. In contrast, interchange-plus pricing (offered by Helcim) passes through what the card networks charge and adds a fixed margin, so you pay less on cheap cards like debit. Learn about flat-rate vs interchange-plus pricing.
  3. Know your monthly volume and average sale. If you process a high volume of credit card transactions, merchant service providers like Helcim that offer interchange-plus pricing and volume discounts will be the best choice.
  4. List every hidden fee, not just the payment processing fees. Check for monthly, payment gateway, PCI compliance, statement, and monthly minimum fees, plus chargeback, refund, instant deposit, currency conversion, and inactivity fees. Ask whether the merchant service provider keeps its fee when you refund a customer and whether you pay a chargeback fee even when you win.
  5. Read the contract before you sign. Look for the term length, POS rental terms, automatic renewal, early termination fees, and liquidated damages. Month-to-month service lets you leave if prices rise or service slips.
  6. Check how you get the payment hardware. Buying a terminal outright is almost always cheaper than a multi-year lease. Also ask whether the hardware only works with that merchant service provider and how long it will be supported.
  7. Compare the payment tools that come with the merchant account. Find out whether the POS, invoicing, recurring billing, online store, customer database, and integrations are free or need a paid plan. Make sure it connects to the accounting and business software you already use.
  8. Confirm it works where you do business. In Canada, check Interac debit rates, PAD bank payments and credit card surcharging. If you sell in both CAD and USD, check whether you need separate paid accounts.
  9. Plan for growth. Ask whether rates drop automatically as you grow or only after you negotiate.

Which merchant service providers are suitable for high-volume sales

For high-volume businesses, the best merchant service providers use interchange-plus pricing and lower their margin as volume grows. Helcim offers interchange-plus pricing for all businesses and a volume discount that can lower credit card processing fees up to 70%. Global Payments, Stripe and PayPal's Braintree can also offer interchange-plus, but only through negotiation, and Square only opens custom pricing above $250,000 a year.

The table below estimates one month of in-person card fees for a U.S. business selling $150,000 a month at an average sale of $50 (3,000 transactions), using each merchant service provider's standard published pricing.

Merchant service providers Costs Estimated monthly cost (USD) Monthly savings with Helcim (USD)
Helcim Average 1.63% + 7¢ ($100K to $500K tier) per transaction, $0 monthly $2,655 Baseline
PayPal 2.29% + 9¢ per transaction $3,705 28.3%
Square Premium 2.4% + 15¢ per transaction + $149/month plan $4,199 36.8%
Stripe 2.7% + 5¢ per transaction $4,200 36.8%
Square Free 2.6% + 15¢ per transaction $4,350 39.0%
Authorize.net All-in-One 2.9% + 30¢ per transaction + $25/month $5,275 49.7%

For a Canadian business with the same sales ($150,000 CAD a month in person, 3,000 transactions averaging $50), the estimate looks like this:

Merchant service providers Costs Estimated monthly cost (CAD) Monthly savings with Helcim (CAD)
Helcim Average 1.57% + 7¢ ($100K to $500K tier) per transaction, $0 monthly $2,565 Baseline
Square 2.5% per transaction $3,750 31.6%
Stripe 2.7% + 5¢ per transaction $4,200 38.9%
Authorize.net All-in-One 2.9% + 30¢ per transaction + $25 gateway $5,275 51.4%

As you can see, for high-volume U.S. and Canadian businesses, they save from 30% to 50% when processing in-person credit card payments with Helcim.

A few things matter more at high volume than at low volume:

  • Automatic discounts: A 0.5% difference on $150,000 a month is $750 a month, or $9,000 a year. Helcim's margin falls at $50,000, $100,000, $500,000 and $1 million in monthly volume without you having to ask.
  • Level 2/3 data: If you sell to other businesses, sending Level 2/3 data on corporate cards can lower costs substantially. Helcim does it automatically (as low as 1.45%). Square has no Level 2/3 savings, and Stripe, PayPal and Authorize.net only pass them on with interchange-plus pricing and the right integration.
  • Bank payments for large invoices: Capped ACH/EFT fees keep large B2B payments cheap. Helcim caps them at $6; Stripe caps U.S. ACH at $5; Square's free plan has no cap.

For most high-volume businesses in the U.S. and Canada, Helcim gives the lowest cost without negotiation. Global Payments can compete for very large enterprises that negotiate hard, and Stripe is the better option when high volume comes from customers in many countries.

FAQ

Which types of businesses are best suited to Helcim merchant services?

Helcim suits small and mid-sized businesses in the U.S. and Canada that want low, transparent fees without a contract. That includes retail stores, restaurants and cafes, salons, contractors and home services, healthcare clinics, professional services, and B2B businesses. Businesses that send invoices, bill on a schedule, take ACH/EFT or HSA/FSA payments, or sell to other businesses on corporate cards get extra value from the built-in tools and automatic Level 2/3 savings. Growing businesses benefit most, because Helcim margin drops automatically as monthly volume rises. Helcim is less suited to businesses based outside North America or to large restaurants that need specialized kitchen systems.

What is the best merchant service provider for high-volume businesses?

For most high-volume businesses in the U.S. and Canada, Helcim is the best fit because it uses interchange-plus pricing with volume discounts of up to 70% that apply automatically, plus custom pricing above $5 million a month. In our example of $150,000 a month in in-person sales, Helcim came to about $2,655 in fees, compared with $3,705 to $5,275 at the other providers with published pricing. Very large enterprises can also negotiate interchange-plus deals with Global Payments, but should watch for multi-year contracts and leases. Businesses whose volume comes from customers worldwide may prefer Stripe for its multi-currency tools.

What is the best merchant service provider for cross-border U.S. and Canada payments?

Helcim is built for businesses on both sides of the border, with separate published rates for each country, ACH in the U.S., EFT/PAD and Interac in Canada, and deposits in USD or CAD. You can run multiple merchant accounts under one Helcim account for different currencies, and Helcim does not add its own currency conversion fee. By comparison, Stripe adds 1% to 2% for currency conversion, PayPal adds 3% to 4%, and Authorize.net needs two $25 monthly accounts to bill in both CAD and USD. Square and PayPal also leave out key Canadian features such as PAD bank payments, and PayPal has no in-person card hardware in Canada.

What is the most affordable merchant service provider?

For most businesses, Helcim is the most affordable because it combines interchange-plus pricing with $0 monthly, PCI, setup, and cancellation fees. Its average U.S. in-person rate is about 1.78% + 8¢, compared with 2.6% + 15¢ at Square and 2.7% + 5¢ at Stripe, and debit cards cost far less. Square or PayPal can cost about the same for a business that only makes a few small sales a month, since neither charges a monthly fee on its basic plan. Before you choose, compare total cost, including chargeback, refund, instant deposit, and currency conversion fees, not just the headline rate.